More and more UK businesses are investing in a cyber insurance policy, and rightly so as even small companies can be hit with ransomware, phishing scams, or data breaches. But here’s the catch: having a policy doesn’t automatically guarantee your insurer will pay out if something goes wrong.
Insurers have started tightening the rules. Claims are being denied more frequently, and providers now demand clear evidence that your business has taken proactive steps to manage cyber risks.
Here’s what that means, and what you can do about it.
Cyber Insurance Policies Are Getting Stricter
Cyber insurance used to be relatively easy to secure, but rising claims have changed the landscape. Insurers now expect you to demonstrate that your systems, staff, and suppliers are all part of a strong, active cyber defence strategy.
Fail to meet these requirements, and your claim could be stalled, reduced, or outright rejected.
Here are six areas that most insurers are now scrutinising when evaluating a claim.
1. No Multi-Factor Authentication? No Payout.
Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) is the baseline.
Many providers now require MFA to be active on:
- Email accounts
- Remote access tools
- Admin-level logins
If you suffer a breach and can’t show that MFA was in place, your cyber insurance policy could be invalidated.
2. Delayed Security Updates and Patching
If your systems aren’t up to date, insurers may argue that you failed to take “reasonable precautions” especially if the attack exploited a known vulnerability that had a fix available.
Your patching strategy should include:
- Prompt installation of critical updates
- Testing updates to avoid conflicts
- Documented update schedules
This helps demonstrate that your business is serious about its security hygiene.
3. Incomplete or Unverified Backups
Backups aren’t just about having a copy of your data, they’re about proving you can recover fast, without further data loss.
Insurers increasingly expect backups to be:
- Regularly tested
- Immutable (cannot be altered by attackers)
- Stored in a secure, off-site or cloud environment
You may be asked to produce evidence that your backup and restore procedures are working — so keep that documentation handy.
4. No Evidence of Security Awareness Training
Human error is still the number one cause of cyber breaches. Insurers know this and now expect you to actively reduce the risk.
Your security awareness training should include:
- Annual (or more frequent) staff training
- Simulated phishing tests
- Documented cybersecurity policies
Without this, your business could be seen as negligent particularly if the breach started with a phishing email or employee misstep.
5. Supply Chain Weaknesses
Your cyber insurance policy may not cover you fully if the incident originated from a third-party supplier. That’s why insurers are paying close attention to supply chain risk.
They may ask:
- Do you evaluate the cyber posture of vendors?
- Are third-party access rights limited?
- Do your contracts include data protection responsibilities?
Supply chain attacks are rising fast and so is scrutiny from underwriters.
6. No Incident Response Plan
You wouldn’t wait until the fire alarm goes off to figure out where the exits are. The same logic applies to cyber incidents.
A well-structured incident response plan shows insurers that you’re prepared, not panicked. It should outline:
- Roles and responsibilities in the first 24 hours
- Internal and external communication processes
- Steps for recovery and investigation
Practicing this plan is just as important as writing it. You may be asked for evidence during your claim.
What You Can Do Now (Before It’s Too Late)
To avoid surprises and protect your business, here’s how to get proactive:
✅ Review Your Policy
Understand exactly what your insurer expects. The fine print matters, especially in the exclusions section.
✅ Speak to Your MSP (That’s Us!)
At Commercial Networks, we help businesses assess and improve their cyber readiness. We’ll review your systems and flag any gaps that could affect your cover.
✅ Document Everything
Keep clear records of:
- Updates and patching
- Backup logs and tests
- Training sessions
- Access reviews
This documentation could be the difference between a successful claim and a rejected one.
✅ Get Cyber Essentials Certified
A Cyber Essentials certification is often required, or at least favoured, by insurers. It shows you’ve got the fundamental controls in place and are serious about cybersecurity.
Cyber Insurance Is Evolving – Is Your IT Keeping Up?
A cyber insurance policy isn’t a get-out-of-jail-free card. It’s a safety net, one that depends on you doing your part.
By putting the right technical and procedural controls in place, you don’t just improve your chances of a successful claim, you reduce the likelihood of needing to make one at all.
If you’re unsure where your business stands, or if your current policy still fits the risks you face, talk to us.
📞 Call 0333 444 3455
📧 Or email sales@cnltd.co.uk to book your cyber risk review
We’ll help you understand what your insurer expects and make sure your systems are ready.
rned into a newsletter, or repurposed for LinkedIn or email campaigns. Gerty is multi-channel ready. 🚀
Further Reading
Cyber Insurance & Policy Guidance
- National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) – Cyber Insurance Guidance for SMEs
- FCA – Operational Resilience & IT Security Expectations
Cyber Essentials & Security Standards
- Cyber Essentials – Official UK Gov Overview
- Cyber Essentials with Commercial Networks
The Real Cost of Cyber Incidents
- Statista – Average Cost of a Data Breach (UK-specific)
- Datto – Downtime Cost Calculator (Interactive)
